Ari Armstrong's Web Log (Main) | Archives | Terms of Use

Reading the Elizabeth Suppressed Books

Colorado's Elizabeth School District marked eighteen books for removal from school library shelves. I decided to read those books plus two others related to the controversy.

by Ari Armstrong, Copyright © 2026

This document (originally posted June 7, 2026) collects the articles and study guides associated with my reading of the twenty books marked for removal by the Elizabeth School District. Updated in 2026: June 8, July 19, August 11

Check back for updates.

Related Articles

Double Standards Led Elizabeth Schools to Suppress 'The Kite Runner'
Colorado Times Recorder
September 21, 2026

The Moral Panic Behind the Elizabeth School District's Suppression of Books
Colorado Times Recorder
July 30, 2026

Elizabeth Conservatives Should Read the Books They Want to Suppress
Colorado Times Recorder
June 10, 2026

A Colorado Librarian Weighs in on Book Bans
Complete Colorado
November 19, 2024

To Raise Tough-Minded Kids, Don't Restrict What They Read
Complete Colorado
October 1, 2024

Would-be Colorado Book Banners are the 'Baddies'
Complete Colorado
December 12, 2023
Discusses a conservative effort to ban certain books and includes a discussion of Darius the Great Deserves Better by Adib Khorram.

The Suppressed Books

I decided to read the eighteen books pulled from school library shelves by the Elizabeth School District, plus another book marked "suspended" but missing from shelves and a book that received a complaint and that at one point was believed by the ACLU to be removed. (See the district's original lists.) My hyperlinks point to my review and study questions for each book. For some books, I included brief notes below.

Beloved is a meditation on the horrors of slavery in the form of a ghost story. Lynda Koolish argues (alternate link) that the ghost can be interpreted as "personality disorder . . . or dissociative states" brought on by severe abuse. Apparently Morrison believed in the possibility of ghosts. Unlike The Bluest Eye, this story ends on a somewhat positive note.

Crank is a powerful warning against substance abuse. It is about a teen girl who, introduced to drugs by her boyfriend and father, becomes hopelessly addicted and destroys her life. In her afterword, "The Story Behind the Crank Trilogy," Hopkins writes, "meth was a plague." She writes of "watching my daughter go from the talented, beautiful girl with big dreams to a meth-wasted, twice-convicted felon." She hoped that, through the book, she "might turn one or two or a thousand young people away from the path that my daughter had chosen." Yes, the book discusses drug abuse and sex, including rape. That is all part of the story of the horrors of drug abuse. I am honestly perplexed by those who suppressed the book: Do they seriously believe youth will do better if they remain ignorant of the horrors of drug abuse? Really?

Burned tells the story of a spirited girl who finds new life after her viciously violent father sends her to live with her aunt for the Summer. Her aunt offers her love, understanding, horseback riding lessons and the freedom to pursue a budding romance. Meanwhile, her father takes a break from beating his wife, who is pregnant, to beat another of his daughters instead. The family's religious community tolerates the abuse. The father already has threatened to murder non-Mormons for dating his sister and daughter, so he's likely to respond violently to his daughter's new romance too. I loved the portrayal of the girl's new life with her aunt. Unfortunately the novel ends very grimly, leading to its sequel, Smoke. Hopkins notes that the book portrays "an extreme (not to mention dysfunctional) example of the LDS faith," not its usual practice. Unfortunately religious tolerance of abuse has occurred. One thing that bothers me about Burned is it suggests the protagonist will become a mass-murderer (she doesn't), but that's totally contrary to her character as previously developed.

Ari Armstrong's Web Log (Main) | Archives | Terms of Use